June GlamBag vs. BirchBox

It seems like beauty product subscription clubs are popping up everyday. I’m a member or Birchbox & My Glam Bag which both send a selection of samples for $10/month.
Anywho here’s what I received this month. First up, 

 

GLAM BAG

Philosophy Take a Deep Breathe energizing oxygen gel cream moisturizer
NYX Round LS in Eucalyptus
Living Proof frizz nourishing styling cream
Marbella Permanent Eyeliner Pen in black  
BIRCHBOX

Eyeko Skinny Liquid Liner in Olive
Melvita Rose Floral Water
theBalm Stainiac in Beauty Queen
Yu-Be Moisturizing Skin Cream
Band Aids w/ Cynthia Rowley prints
John Varvatos Cologne Sample (special man extra for father’s day)
I haven’t really got to play with any of these products too much yet but upon first glance I’m a little more pleased with the Glam Bag. Overall if I had to recomend one service over the other I would go Glam Bag because they generally have more makeup type products from popular brands, which I prefer, while Birchbox generally has more skincare products then makeup products. Also I can do without some of the extras Birchbox sends, I would rather have bigger/better product samples.